The Hunting Wives ends with Sophie deciding to run over Margo’s brother Kyle (Michael Aaron Milligan) after he threatens her. In doing so, Sophie — who has been drinking and driving — chooses to repeat the same crime that has haunted her for the past two years when she killed another motorist while intoxicated.

Cobb’s novel, Netflix’s The Hunting Wives has it all: buried secrets, open-carry guns, bisexual affairs, kidnapped teens, questionable parenting, swinging politicians, and corrupt clergy. The show, which TIME’s critic described as “the wildest,